Saint Catherine Lake Real Estate

Welcome to the serene beauty of Saint Catherine Lake, nestled in the picturesque Rutland County of Vermont. This hidden gem is not just a body of water; it's a tranquil escape that embodies the essence of New England charm. Surrounded by lush forests and rolling hills, Saint Catherine Lake offers a perfect backdrop for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers alike.

The lake spans approximately 200 acres, providing ample opportunities for recreational activities. Whether you’re looking to cast a line for some fishing, take a leisurely kayak ride, or simply enjoy a peaceful day by the water, Saint Catherine Lake has it all. The crystal-clear waters are ideal for swimming during the warm summer months, and the scenic shoreline is perfect for picnics and family gatherings.

In addition to its natural beauty, the area surrounding Saint Catherine Lake is rich in local culture and history. The nearby town of Rutland boasts charming shops, delightful restaurants, and vibrant community events. Explore the local art scene or enjoy a cozy evening at one of the many cafes that line the quaint streets.

For those considering a move to this enchanting area, the real estate options are as diverse as the landscape. From charming lakeside cottages to expansive family homes, there’s something for everyone looking to embrace the Vermont lifestyle.

Discover the magic of Saint Catherine Lake and experience the perfect blend of tranquility and adventure in Rutland County. Your dream home awaits amidst the breathtaking beauty of this remarkable region!

Newest Listings in Saint Catherine Lake

$325,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5108341 MLS

Enjoy the best of Vermont lakefront living with this charming 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom seasonal camp in Poultney, VT. Showcasing direct access to the ultra desirable Lake St. Catherine, this is the perfect oasis for an incredible 2nd property on one of the states most coveted locations. Situated on 0.40 acres along a peaceful inlet, this property offers a quiet and relaxing setting with beautiful surroundings in every direction. Inside, the kitchen, dining, and living areas flow perfectly together, creating a comfortable space for gathering after a day on the water. A wood stove provides warmth during those cooler Vermont nights, while the screened-in porch is the perfect spot to enjoy the fresh air and peaceful surroundings throughout the entirety of the warmer seasons. On the exterior, you'll love the generously sized Trex deck put in just a few years back, offering an abundance of space for outdoor dining, entertaining, and relaxing right on your privately owned shore. A dock provides convenient water access for fishing, kayaking, and enjoying everything lake life has to offer, plus the inlet does provide direct access to the larger portion of Lake St. Catherine for those boat enthusiasts that want to dock right at your doorstep! An additional shed provides ample storage for tools, outdoor equipment, and lake toys. Whether you're looking for a weekend retreat or a seasonal Vermont getaway, this lakefront camp offers a wonderful opportunity to slow down, enjoy the water, and make lasting memories. Schedule your tour today!

309 Cones Point Rd, Poultney

$350,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5102207 MLS

A LAKEFRONT OPPORTUNITY! Welcome summers every year at Lake St. Catherine at this affordable, adorable and very charming 970 sq ft. cabin. There is little to do in this low key, move in ready retreat so enjoy lazy afternoons with crystal clear swimming, fishing or boating right off your own private boat dock. The huge lake facing open porch with swing offers hours of entertaining. Whether reading the latest novel, playing a game of cards, a board game, enjoying a meal or your favorite cocktail , the miles of sparkling water views and stunning sunsets will not disappoint. This two room cabin with heat pump provides heat and air. If your long time dream is owning a lake front property but do not want to break the bank, this Vermont getaway with 270 +/- feet of pristine lake front may check all the boxes. Located on Route 30 so access to the state beach, country club and the slate valley bike trails are less than 5 minutes away. Come see one of the prettiest lakes in Vermont and witness the privacy and serenity that this gem offers.

4457 Vt Route 30, Wells

$595,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5090571 MLS

Relax with sweeping mountain and lake views from atop a hillside in this beautifully maintained Cape Cod-style residence that offers wildlife, creature comforts and modern convenience. Set in the picturesque town of Wells, Vermont, enjoy easy access to Pond Mountain and Lake St. Catherine in the heart of the Lake Region. Approximately 2,680 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, featuring hardwood floors that lend timeless New England character throughout. The spacious sun-lit entry room with open flow concept kitchen provides plenty of room for entertaining. Enjoy watching the deer prance in the valley below gorgeous mountain ranges from the formal dining room. Take in the sun dappled fall foliage and birds flocking to the apple blossoms from the cozy living room with a fireplace to ward off the chill of snowy winters. Main floor laundry and 1 half bath complete the first level, 2 full baths on the second floor. The basement offers ample usable opportunities. Let your imagination run wild from the dedicated second-floor office/artist space, an ideal retreat for remote work or quiet reflection. Catch a fiery sunset or soak in the calming sunrise over the misty lake from the primary suite, with windows in the walk-in closet and well-appointed bath. Spectacular mountain and/or lake views enchant all four of the comfortable second floor rooms. Outside, a gracious front porch invites you to relax and take in the peaceful setting, while an attached 2-car garage and substantial 20 x 30 heated barn with a concrete floor add versatility and convenience. Just a short walk to Wells Lakeside Park and the marina on Lake St. Catherine, with boat slips available, this exceptional property offers easy access to four-season recreation, shopping, dining, and premier regional destinations including Manchester, Lake George, Bromley, Okemo, Killington, Lake St. Catherine Golf Course, and Slate Valley Mt. bike trails. This is where scenic beauty meets Vermont living!

1704 North St, Wells

$800,000

5090225 MLS

Rare opportunity to own a waterfront lot on the peaceful shores of Lake St. Catherine with substantial State permitting and planning work already completed. Tucked away in protected Oxbow Bay near the island, this special property offers beautiful lake frontage, mature trees, private docks, and a sandy beach in one of the lake’s more sheltered and scenic settings. The current owners have invested significant time and effort into advancing the property for future development, including obtaining a State of Vermont Wastewater System and Potable Water Supply Permit for a proposed two-bedroom residence with onsite well and advanced wastewater system. Shoreland Protection permitting associated with the proposed improvements has also been obtained, providing buyers with meaningful due diligence and planning work already completed. Located on Peninsula Drive, a private road offering privacy and a tucked-away lake setting, the property currently includes a platform with a wall tent, creating an enjoyable seasonal retreat while future plans are explored. Lake St. Catherine is one of Vermont’s select wake boating lakes, and this location offers a unique balance of recreation and protection. Enjoy boating, kayaking, swimming, fishing, and lake life while the sheltered bay helps protect the shoreline, beach area, and docked boats from heavier wave activity. Whether you are seeking a peaceful seasonal escape or exploring the potential for a future lakeside home, this property offers a rare combination of waterfront beauty, privacy, and valuable permitting progress already in place.

123 Peninsula Dr, Poultney

$839,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5082936 MLS

Nestled on the southwest shore of beautiful Lake St. Catherine, which is one of Vermont's best kept secrets, it's lakeshore living at it's best! This picturesque double lot, boasting 150' of lakeshore and over a half acre is accented with the most gorgeous views that you'll ever experience. From the moment that you enter this year round residence built in 1990, you will be enchanted with the beauty of this open concept living where the lake and mountain view fills every corner. Whether you are dining, relaxing, entertaining or cooking in the newly installed 2022 kitchen, it is a slice of heaven. Red birch cabinets, granite countertops, a marble subway tile backsplash, s/s appliances and a large island for prepping your finest meal. This sunfilled room has thoughtful builtins, providing space for your books or finest collectables. The two sliders provides entry to your lake facing deck, a perfect spot for your morning coffee while taking in the glorious sunrise . There are three very comfortable bedrooms including a primary ensuite with luxury bath. The walk-in tile shower, large vanity with Granite countertop and the lake view is everyone's dream. The hardwood floors that flow throughout brings added charm and warmth. If this is not enough, the seller just had built a 24x24 garage with loft and attached is a 16x22 unfinished room providing ample space for vehicles, storage and outdoor toys. The fully poured concrete walk out basement houses the laundry area and a newer hot air furnace provides not only heat but central air. A covered porch the length of house with a Pergola is an added bonus and great for dining, playing cards, board games, reading or an afternoon cocktail. Indulge in four season recreation and embrace the ultimate lakeside lifestyle with peace, serenity and natural beauty. A perfect location to fish, kayak or canoe. This well loved home is ready for its next chapter. Let it be your opportunity. Fully furnished.

48 Western Shores Rd, Wells

Start Your Search

board logo Copyright 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this display comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated .