Poultney Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Poultney, Vermont, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Rutland County! This charming town, rich in history and surrounded by the stunning landscapes of the Green Mountains, offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern amenities. With its picturesque streets and vibrant community spirit, Poultney is an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.

One of the most appealing aspects of Poultney is its affordability. Homes in this delightful town can be found for under $500,000, making it an attractive option for first-time homebuyers or those seeking a peaceful retreat without breaking the bank. From cozy single-family homes to charming historic properties, the real estate market here offers a variety of options to suit different tastes and budgets.

Imagine waking up to the serene beauty of the Vermont countryside, where outdoor adventures await at every turn. Whether you enjoy hiking, fishing, or simply taking in the breathtaking views, Poultney's natural surroundings provide endless opportunities for exploration and relaxation. The town also boasts a strong sense of community, with local events, farmers' markets, and friendly neighbors who make you feel right at home.

If you're considering a move to a place that combines affordability, charm, and a welcoming atmosphere, Poultney, VT, is the perfect destination. Discover your dream home in this enchanting town and experience the best of Vermont living!

Newest Poultney Homes under $500,000

$259,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5113872 MLS

Welcome to this charming village home tucked away on a quiet side street in Poultney, offering the perfect blend of convenience, comfort, and inviting indoor and outdoor living! Within walking distance to Poultney Elementary School and the nearby Rail Trail, you'll enjoy easy access to walking, biking, and snowmobiling while still appreciating the peaceful setting and minimal traffic. Step outside and discover a large, private yard complete with a detached two-car garage and an attached rear shed, providing plenty of room for storage, hobbies, and projects. The enclosed back porch, filled with windows, overlooks raised garden beds and creates a wonderful spot to unwind while taking in the backyard views. Gather around the firepit with family and friends and enjoy the privacy of your outdoor space, where you may forget you're right in the village! The enclosed front porch offers another inviting spot to enjoy your morning coffee. Inside, you'll find beautiful wood floors and natural wood trim that add warmth and character throughout. The kitchen flows into the dining room and living room, creating a comfortable layout for everyday living and entertaining. Two first-floor bedrooms, both featuring generous closets, and a full bathroom offer the convenience of single-level living. Looking for extra space or future possibilities? The full basement already includes a half bath and laundry area, offering excellent potential to finish and create additional living space. The walk-up attic provides even more bonus space and was previously enjoyed as a hangout area complete with a movie screen. Lovingly cared for and ready for its next chapter, this home offers plenty to enjoy just as it is, with exciting possibilities to make it your own. Come discover the charm, space, and potential of village living in Poultney!

61 Norton Ave, Poultney

$215,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5111517 MLS

UPDATE: Due to strong interest in the property, all offers due by Monday October 12th at 9AM with deadline for acceptance no earlier than Tuesday October 13th at 5PM. Your ticket into the beautiful community of Poultney, VT could be this affordable and nicely maintained 3-bedroom Cape! From the wraparound porch, enter into a home with a library, dining room, pleasant kitchen, and office on the first floor, with all three bedrooms and another room above on the second. Outside is a 1-car garage with storage space above. A short walk or drive to the town center of Poultney and you can avail yourself of the town's restaurants and groceries. Contact agent to schedule a showing. It may not last long!

610 E Main St, Poultney

$362,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5110167 MLS

Check out this amazing property situated On the Green in charming East Poultney, Vermont. The upstairs apartment is currently rented on a month-to-month basis, offering a great opportunity for additional income. The ground level space has a rich history as a general store and presents endless possibilities for its future use. This historic property has a fascinating past, having served as a chair factory in the late 1800s before being relocated to its current spot. Moreover, a spacious carriage house adjacent to the main dwelling adds to the allure of the property. The vibrant community events during the summer make this location even more appealing.

11 On The Green St, Poultney

$475,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5109642 MLS

Welcome to your own private Vermont retreat in charming East Poultney! Set on 10.60 acres, this custom built 2008 home offers the perfect blend of privacy, recreation, and comfortable single level living. Thoughtfully designed for the previous owner, the home also offers handicap-accessible features for added ease and convenience. Tucked away in a peaceful private setting yet just minutes from town, you’ll enjoy seclusion when you want it and convenience when you need it. The partially fenced acreage was previously used for keeping animals and includes a small barn ready to be brought back to life with a little TLC. Outdoor enthusiasts will love the direct access to Slate Valley Mountain Biking Trails and snowmobile trails, putting year-round adventure right outside your door. Beautiful Vermont sunsets can be enjoyed from the spacious wraparound deck, which transitions into a covered front porch, perfect for morning coffee or relaxing evenings. Inside, the single-level layout features a large kitchen flowing into the dining area, bamboo flooring in the living room and all three bedrooms, and radiant heat throughout the main floor and basement. The private primary suite includes a 3/4 bath and washer/dryer hookups. On chilly Vermont days, bring the pellet stove back to life and create a cozy place to unwind. The huge walkout basement provides abundant storage, workspace, and flexibility, with a garage area for two cars. Additional features include a radon mitigation system and wiring in place for geothermal heating. The current owner has completed valuable due diligence, including water testing and a septic inspection, with documentation available. Located less than 15 minutes from Lake St. Catherine and Lake Bomoseen and within 45 minutes of several ski areas and Manchester, this property offers easy access to year-round recreation. Private acreage, trails at your doorstep, room for animals, accessible single-level living, and a wonderful East Poultney setting!

200 Chelsea Ln, Poultney

$275,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5109128 MLS

Step into a beautiful piece of Vermont history! Throughout the home, you'll find timeless details including built-ins, French doors, decorative fireplaces, and the kind of charm that tells a story with every room. Offering 3 bedrooms and 1½ bathrooms, this home has plenty of space and potential to make it your own. The kitchen offers an ample amount of storage, while the large formal dining room provides the perfect setting for gatherings and entertaining. A beautiful sitting room welcomes you with stunning wood floors and elegant glass French doors, creating a warm and inviting space that perfectly showcases the character of this historic home. An attached 2 car garage adds convenience, while the impressive 1.40 acre lot provides a generous amount of outdoor space especially hard to find within the Town of Poultney. The property also features a beautiful antique barn, adding even more character and potential for storage, hobbies, a workshop, or whatever your vision may be. While the home does need some repairs and updating, the potential is truly something special. With its classic Colonial design, original features, large town lot, attached garage, and antique barn, this property offers a rare opportunity to bring a piece of Vermont history back to life. They truly don't make them like this anymore!

1441 E Main St, Poultney

$330,000

5106490 MLS

Welcome to 41 Furnace Street in the quaint town of Poultney - This beautifully renovated two-unit duplex offers modern finishes, extensively updated mechanical systems, and excellent long-term flexibility for an owner-occupant or investor. The property was completely gutted to the studs and renovated in 2023, with nearly every major component of the home replaced or upgraded. Property Layout • Unit 1 – First Floor: 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, with private in-unit laundry • Unit 2 – Second Floor: 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, with private in-unit laundry The extensive renovation included a new roof, new windows, all-new electrical, all-new plumbing, new hydronic heating system, new insulation throughout, new drywall, new kitchens and bathrooms, updated vinyl plank flooring throughout, new recessed lighting and updated fixtures. The new hydronic heating system utilizes a combination of panel radiators and baseboard heat. Each apartment is independently zoned for heating, providing separate temperature control. The electrical system was upgraded to a three-meter service, with separate meters for the first-floor unit, second-floor unit, and common/house service. The house meter primarily covers the electrical components associated with the heating system, while electrical usage for each apartment is separately metered. The upstairs 3-bedroom unit is currently occupied by an existing tenant and generates $1,560 per month through low-income/affordable housing program through NeighborWorks, with approximately three years remaining in the program, The current lease is in place through July 31, 2027, providing immediate and predictable rental income for a new owner. The downstairs 2-bedroom unit is not subject to this restriction and may be utilized as the new owner sees fit, offering flexibility for owner occupancy or traditional rental use. There's few rentals on the market with renovations, steady income, and low maintenace. Don't miss your opportunity!

41 Furnace St, Poultney

$270,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5105960 MLS

BEAUTIFULL RENOVATED VILLAGE COLONIAL WITH EXCEPTIONAL GARAGE AND WORKSHOP SPACE! This spacious village colonial was fully renovated in 2014, including updated wiring, new insulation, new sheetrock and new roofing. The thoughtfully designed layout offers comfortable living spaces and plenty of room for storage, hobbies, and everyday living. The spacious kitchen features a convenient breakfast counter and ample dining space, making it a welcoming gathering area. The first-floor primary bedroom includes a private bathroom and dual closets. A mudroom entry with built-in storage provides a practical transition into the home, while the main level also offers a bonus room and laundry area. The living room is conveniently located just off the kitchen, creating an easy functional flow. Upstairs, you'll find two additional bedrooms and a full bathroom with a double-sink vanity. The property also offers exceptional garage and workshop space. An attached barn style garage provides convenient access to the home, while a detached 25' x 30' steel garage features automatic doors, 220 -amp power, a frost-free water pump, and a workshop in the rear- ideal for projects, hobbies or additional storage. Enjoy outdoor living with a beautiful front patio accented by a stone flower bed, plus a private patio behind the garage that's perfect for morning coffee or relaxing quiet evenings. A well-maintained home with generous living space, excellent storage, versatile garage facilities, and inviting outdoor areas. Close to Lake St. Catherine, close to hiking/biking trails, close to golf course, close to snowmobile trails.

214 Beaman St, Poultney

$185,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5104075 MLS

Spacious contemporary home close to the elementary school and all in-town conveniences. This home offers 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, including a second-floor primary en-suite. The living room in front and the dining room/family room off the kitchen offer comfortable, generous space for everyday living, while the front entry doubles as a natural mudroom for gear and storage. Outside, the fenced yard is thoughtfully zoned with a dedicated dog area and a separate, shaded spot for relaxing under mature trees. Long-term tenants recently vacated after 15 years, leaving this home ready for a fresh start. Roll up your sleeves and with some updates, improvements and landscaping, it can become your home sweet home!.. *RECENT UPDATES INCLUDE NEW ROOF AND ELECTRIC PANEL

208 Allen Ave, Poultney

$289,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5103278 MLS

Step back in time with this stunning Victorian Gothic Revival home, beautifully situated on nearly half an acre in the quaint village of picturesque Poultney, Vermont. Showcasing the elegance of the Gilded Age, this remarkable residence features a steeply pitched slate roof, decorative trim, pointed arch windows, and intricate ornamental woodwork that reflect the prosperity and craftsmanship of Poultney's rich architectural past. The expansive carriage house, once home to grand carriages and livestock, now offers abundant space for one or more vehicles, hobbies, workshops, and additional storage. Outside, the generous lawn provides ample room for gardens, outdoor entertaining, and family games. Inside, the thoughtfully updated kitchen with a cozy breakfast nook blends seamlessly with the home's grand formal dining room, creating the perfect balance of historic charm and modern convenience. The spacious living room and elegant parlor offer inviting spaces to relax, gather, or entertain guests. The first-floor primary bedroom and three generously sized bedrooms upstairs, provide comfortable accommodations for a growing family, visiting guests, or flexible home office space. Rich in history, architectural detail, and timeless character, this exceptional property offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Vermont's heritage while enjoying the comforts of everyday living.

261 Church St, Poultney

$499,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5102047 MLS

Escape to your own private Vermont sanctuary, nestled on over 10 beautiful acres of rolling countryside. Surrounded by mature apple trees and sugar maples, this exceptional property offers the perfect balance of privacy, nature, and comfortable country living. A peaceful brook meanders through the land, creating a serene backdrop where the soothing sounds of flowing water can be enjoyed year-round. Built in 1999 with quality craftsmanship and thoughtful attention to detail, this home has been lovingly maintained by its original owner. Designed for convenient one-level living, the home features a spacious primary suite, a second bedroom, an additional office or flex room, and a second full bathroom, providing a functional layout for everyday living, guests, or working from home.Storage is never a concern with both an attached two-car garage and a detached garage, offering plenty of space for vehicles, recreational equipment, tools, and all your outdoor toys. Step outside and discover all this remarkable property has to offer. Wander through your own orchard to the charming sugarhouse, where the maple trees are ready to be tapped, allowing you to experience one of Vermont’s most treasured traditions. Whether you’re harvesting apples, making maple syrup, or simply enjoying the abundant wildlife and peaceful surroundings, every season brings something special. This is more than just a home—it’s a lifestyle. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a weekend retreat, or your own slice of Vermont paradise, this rare property offers the tranquility, natural beauty, and timeless charm that make Vermont living so special.

2500 Morse Hollow Rd, Poultney

$349,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5101392 MLS

Step into the cozy cottage core farmhouse you've been dreaming of! Nestled on the outskirts of Poultney, just over the Castleton line, this charming 1840s farmhouse offers the perfect blend of timeless character, thoughtful updates, and country living on approximately 3 beautiful acres. The heart of the home is the sun-filled kitchen, where oversized windows flood the space with natural light. A large center island provides the perfect spot for meal prep, casual dining, or gathering with family and friends. Just off the kitchen, enjoy your morning coffee or evening sunsets from the porch overlooking the rolling property and stunning mountain views. A charming French door leads down the hall to a full bathroom and inviting dining room, which flows seamlessly into the cozy living room. Also on the first floor is a versatile bonus room that can easily serve as a bedroom, home office, playroom, or hobby space to fit your lifestyle. Upstairs, you'll find four additional rooms along with a second full bathroom, offering plenty of flexibility for bedrooms, guest space, or work from home needs. Modern upgrades provide comfort and efficiency while preserving the home's historic charm, including newer windows, three heat pump units, and blown-in insulation throughout. Outside, the magic continues. A spacious storage shed offers room for lawn equipment, small vehicles, or could even become the ultimate gathering space for entertaining. The beautiful slate patio crafted from slate sourced right from the property is the perfect place to relax and soak in the peaceful surroundings. Wander to the far end of the property to pick fresh blueberries from your own bushes and enjoy everything this picturesque setting has to offer. Rarely does a property capture the warmth, charm, and character of a true Vermont farmhouse quite like this. Full of history, surrounded by natural beauty, and thoughtfully updated for modern living, this one-of-a-kind home is ready to welcome i

31 Amerio Rd, Poultney

$245,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5100914 MLS

Nestled in a beautiful private rural setting, this charming three-bedroom farmhouse offers the perfect blend of country living and modern comfort. The newly renovated, spacious eat-in kitchen serves as the heart of the home, ideal for gathering with family and friends. Inside, you'll find an open-concept floor plan enhanced by soaring cathedral ceilings, abundant natural light, and warm natural woodwork throughout. The spacious living room is anchored by a cozy wood-burning stove, creating an inviting space to relax year-round. The home features a comfortable primary bedroom suite along with two additional well-sized bedrooms, providing plenty of room for family or guests. Outside, the level yard offers ample space for gardens, outdoor recreation, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Conveniently located just minutes from the village, this property also provides easy access to the Rail Trail, hiking and biking trails, and the VAST trail system, making it an excellent choice for outdoor enthusiasts. Experience the beauty of country living without sacrificing convenience in this delightful Vermont farmhouse.

1276 York Street Ext, Poultney

Start Your Search

board logo Copyright 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this display comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated .