Shrewsbury Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Shrewsbury, Vermont – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Rutland County. Known for its picturesque landscapes, charming rural ambiance, and a tight-knit community, Shrewsbury offers a unique blend of tranquility and outdoor adventure. With rolling hills, lush forests, and sparkling streams, this quaint town provides the perfect backdrop for those seeking a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life.

Shrewsbury is rich in history and character, featuring a variety of local shops, cozy cafes, and community events that bring residents together. Outdoor enthusiasts will revel in the abundance of recreational opportunities, from hiking and biking trails to fishing and skiing in the nearby Green Mountains. The town's welcoming spirit and stunning natural beauty make it an ideal place to call home.

For those looking to invest in a property in this idyllic setting, Shrewsbury offers a selection of charming homes priced under $500,000. Whether you’re seeking a quaint cottage, a spacious family home, or a serene retreat, you’ll find a range of options that cater to various lifestyles and preferences. With competitive pricing and the allure of small-town living, these homes present an excellent opportunity for first-time buyers, families, or anyone looking to embrace the Vermont lifestyle.

Discover the magic of Shrewsbury, where every day feels like a vacation, and the community feels like family. Your dream home awaits in this enchanting corner of Vermont!

Newest Shrewsbury Homes under $500,000

$439,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5109474 MLS

Tucked into the rolling countryside of Lincoln Hill, this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom farmhouse offers the perfect blend of classic Vermont character and everyday comfort. Step inside to find warm, sun-filled rooms, timeless farmhouse details, original pine floors, and a layout designed for both quiet living and easy gathering. Four spacious bedrooms provide room to grow, host, or simply spread out, while the classic architecture and thoughtful updates create a home that feels both historic and move-in ready. Outside, a wonderful 1.1-acre level, private lot is framed by mature maples, offering shade, privacy, and classic New England beauty year-round. A rustic antique barn rounds out the property, ideal for housing farm animals, storing equipment, or supporting a hobby farm, which is a true nod to the land's agricultural roots. Enjoy the peaceful, private setting of Lincoln Hill, yet you're just minutes from the heart of Shrewsbury, a town known for its tight-knit community, scenic charm, and small-town warmth. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, a weekend escape, or a home with room to make lasting memories, this Lincoln Hill farmhouse checks every box.

2541 Lincoln Hill Rd, Shrewsbury

$150,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5109284 MLS

Imagine the Possibilities! Bring your vision and make this fixer-upper your own. Situated on 3.94 acres, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers plenty of opportunity for renovation, investment, or creating your primary residence. The property has a one-car garage and a large storage shed, providing additional space for vehicles, tools, equipment, and storage. The first floor features a kitchen, is plumbed and set up for a first floor bathroom, living room with a woodstove, and a first-floor bedroom. If you only need two bedrooms, the first-floor bedroom could easily be transformed into a comfortable dining room, office, or additional living space. Upstairs are two additional bedrooms. With some creativity, the space could potentially accommodate a third sleeping area, or the layout could be reimagined to create a home office, walk-in closet, or even an additional bathroom, depending on your renovation plans. Whether you're looking for a project to flip, renovate and resell, or create a home tailored to your own needs, this property offers a great opportunity to put your ideas to work.

6718 Cold River Rd, Shrewsbury

$399,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5107656 MLS

There’s a certain kind of Vermont life that’s getting harder to find, but at 387 Wilmouth Hill, you’ll find it waiting for you. Up in the hills, this sweet property offers room to spread out, peace and quiet to unwind, and the freedom to make a little piece of Vermont your own. The main level is designed for easy living, with the kitchen, dining, and living spaces flowing together for a relaxed feel. Sliding doors lead right from the dining room onto the large deck, so grab your coffee and stay awhile; the view is worth it. And because this is Vermont, the whole-house generator is one of those features you’ll be especially grateful for when the weather decides not to cooperate. Three bedrooms offer plenty of flexibility, whether you need space for guests, a home office, playroom, or something entirely your own. The smallest bedroom is partially finished and ready for its next chapter, and with a seller credit you can finish the space to fit your needs. Downstairs, an existing bar area sets the stage for a game room, après-ski hangout, or favorite spot to entertain. Mother Nature does a lot of the decorating here; there is room for dogs to run, gardens to grow, trails to wander, and evenings spent watching the seasons change around you. Weekends can mean hiking, skiing, or simply enjoying having nowhere else to be; all while being surprisingly close to everything. Rutland is less than 15 minutes away for shopping, dining, and everyday essentials, while Killington and Okemo are an easy 30 minute drive when the mountains are calling. Whether you’re buying your first home, looking for an investment, or simply craving an easier, quieter way of life, this is the place to slow down, breathe a little deeper, and enjoy the kind of Vermont life you came here for. OPEN HOUSE on Saturday October 10 from 1-3pm.

387 Wilmouth Hill Rd, Shrewsbury

$395,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5104494 MLS

Discover the perfect blend of comfort and character in this beautifully updated bungalow, nestled in the heart of Cuttingsville. Ideally positioned for convenience, you are just a short drive from the amenities of both Rutland and Ludlow. This home has been thoughtfully renovated and meticulously maintained. Set back from the road, it is framed by enchanting perennial gardens that offer a sense of privacy and peace. The Home: The journey begins in the spacious, welcoming mudroom. Step inside to an inviting kitchen that flows seamlessly into the large living room, where a cozy woodstove creates the perfect atmosphere for relaxation. Throughout the home, you’ll find classic charm preserved in the original trim and warm wood floors. Main Level Living: The primary floor is designed for easy living, featuring a formal dining room, two comfortable bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a convenient laundry area. Upstairs Retreat: The upper level provides a generous third bedroom and a flexible space perfectly suited for a home office, studio, or craft room. Outdoor Space: Outside, the detached one-car garage offers both protection for your vehicle and abundant storage solutions. This bungalow is more than just a home; it’s a retreat that celebrates both classic craftsmanship and modern, comfortable living. We invite you to experience its charm firsthand. Seller must find suitable housing to close on this property.

5187 Vt Route 103, Shrewsbury

$130,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5093118 MLS

This cabin and property are going to be absolutely perfect for someone...It may be a single person or a couple just getting started. It could be an outdoorsman looking for a cabin to use as home base for hunting or cycling. Skiers might like it instead of renting. I would bet that hikers will love the fact that this cabin is within sight of the Appalachian Trail! The famous Clarendon Gorge and swimming hole is a 5 minute walk across the road. The cabin is small....kitchen/living room, bedroom, and full bath, but what else do you need? The property is 17 acres subdivided from the family farm. What used to be pastures is now all wooded. There is an old woods road that runs through. There is frontage on Route 103, but also about 1700 feet of frontage on a Class IV town gravel road. There is an ample spring for water, and a septic system approved for 2 people. The propane wall unit takes care of the heat. This location is convenient to Rutland and a short trip to Okemo in Ludlow or Killington. Enjoy all Mother Nature has to offer...you will have occasional visiting wildlife pass by. Simple living appeals to so many, you may be the one!

2183 Rte 103, Unit Lot 2, Shrewsbury

Start Your Search

board logo Copyright 2026 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this display comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, noncommercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated .